Topic: Damages

The Ontario Superior Court dismisses a generic manufacturer’s claim for damages under section 8 of the PM(NOC) Regulations

The Ontario Superior Court (ONSC) has dismissed a claim for damages under section 8 of the Patented Medicines (Notice of Compliance) Regulations (the Regulations) brought by Apotex Inc. (Apotex) for lost sales of its Apo-Atomoxetine product. The Court conducted a purposive interpretation of the Regulations and found that Apotex did not meet the statutory requirements … Continue reading

Supreme Court denies leave to appeal in generic Statute of Monopolies case

By William Chalmers, Christopher A. Guerreiro and David Yi on May 4, 2023 Posted in Damages, Intellectual property, Life sciences and healthcare

On April 27, 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed an application by Apotex Inc. and Apotex Pharmachem Inc. (Apotex) for leave to appeal from a decision of the Ontario Court of Appeal (ONCA), dismissing its claim for damages in the Ontario courts under the Statutes of Monopolies and other novel causes of action. In the Courts below, Apotex … Continue reading

Higher costs awards coming to the Federal Court, including for pharma regulatory and IP disputes

By Chelsea Nimmo, Paul Jorgensen and Kristin Wall on February 26, 2023 Posted in Damages, Intellectual property, Life sciences and healthcare, Pharmaceuticals and life sciences

Higher costs awards for Federal Court litigation are on the horizon, with the Canadian government consulting on proposed amendments to the costs structure in the Federal Courts Rules (the Rules). The proposed amendments are intended to increase costs awards by approximately 25%. The current costs regime Under the Rules, the Federal Courts can fix a … Continue reading

Pharma in Brief: The 2022 Year in Review

By William Chalmers, Christopher A. Guerreiro, Paul Jorgensen and Kristin Wall on January 25, 2023 Posted in Damages, Intellectual property, Life sciences and healthcare, Pharmaceuticals and life sciences

Does 2022 already seem like a blur? The Pharma in Brief team is here for you with a summary of some of 2022’s most significant legal and regulatory developments in the Canadian pharmaceutical space. We also flag what to watch out for in 2023. The most significant legislative changes concerned the Patent Act and … Continue reading

ONCA Confirms Generics Limited to Section 8 Damages in the Face of an Innovator’s Legitimate Exercise of Rights under the PM(NOC) Regulations

By Allyson Whyte Nowak, David Yi and Christopher A. Guerreiro on August 25, 2022 Posted in Damages, Intellectual property, Life sciences and healthcare, Pharmaceuticals and life sciences

On August 16, 2022, the Ontario Court of Appeal (ONCA) released its decision in Apotex Inc. v. Eli Lilly Canada Inc., 2022 ONCA 587. The ONCA denied Apotex’s appeal of a lower court summary judgement decision that dismissed Apotex’s novel claims under the UK and Ontario Statutes of Monopolies, the Trademarks Act, and at common law (see … Continue reading

Ontario Superior Court summarily dismisses Apotex’s novel monetary claims under Statutes of Monopolies, Trademarks Act, and at common law

By David Yi and Allyson Whyte Nowak on March 18, 2021 Posted in Damages, Intellectual property, Life sciences and healthcare, Pharmaceuticals and life sciences

On March 8, 2021, the Ontario Superior Court granted summary judgment dismissing novel claims by Apotex under the UK and Ontario Statutes of Monopolies, the Trademarks Act, and at common law. It is the first decision on the merits of Apotex’s novel claims and arises in the context of litigation relating to Eli Lilly’s patented … Continue reading

Finality, finally: Adir and Servier Canada Inc. confirm their perindopril win

By Pharma in Brief team on November 1, 2020 Posted in Damages, Intellectual property, Life sciences and healthcare, Pharmaceuticals and life sciences

The 14 year perindopril litigation in Canada is over, with Adir and Servier Canada Inc. (collectively “Servier”) emerging victorious against Apotex Inc. and Apotex Pharmachem Inc. (collectively “Apotex”). The end was marked by the Supreme Court of Canada’s dismissal of Apotex’s application for leave to appeal a decision requiring it to disgorge its profits associated … Continue reading

Federal Court reinstates damages decision concerning prejudgment interest

By David Yi, Allyson Whyte Nowak and Pharma in Brief team on January 15, 2020 Posted in Damages

The Federal Court has vindicated Lilly, reinstating a patent infringement damages decision that awarded Lilly prejudgment interest equal to its average annual rate of return during the interest earning period, on a compound basis. It found that Lilly’s real-world rate of return was convincing evidence of both what could have and what would have occurred … Continue reading